It’s absolutely amazing that people who actively comment on economic models don’t actually understand them. Why don’t they use google if their education failed them? Mind boggling.
KingMurk817 on
Education is so important to a functioning society.
timblunts on
We are a nation of marks
CG-Firebrand on
One of the best tricks performed against the working class was convincing them all the bad stuff in the world wasn’t in part caused by capitalism, so the more bad stuff means we aren’t capitalisming hard enough. Gotta throw more money at top percenters and corpos so they can “make jobs” and “reinvest in the region”.
Jebis on
All of the rowers should be seated facing the same way with their backs to the prow
Soliden on
Management: “We’re all on the same boat together.”
The boat:
18ekko on
The real problem this image demonstrates is that this is what communism looks like when it goes wrong, but what capitalism looks like when it’s working exactly as designed.
HotDoggityDig13 on
Homo sapiens you mean
u_touch_my_tra_la_la on
Where the fuck is that boat going with that rower bank config?
Coveinant on
Both are wrong, that’s oligarchy period.
all_time_high on
Are we sure it’s not aristocracy?
Silentparty1999 on
Is that a picture of Bezos yacht?
Generic_Username26 on
This image could apply to both equally. In both societies you have rich and poor. Communism doesn’t magically erase societal classes at least it hasn’t in any society it’s been implemented in.
scfw0x0f on
The problem is there has never been a genuinely Communist state, in which the workers actually owned and controlled the means of production. There were a series of dictators from Stalin on in Russia and Mao on in China. In Russia or China, the apparatchik leaders would be the ones on the top deck and the ordinary workers are the galley slaves.
It’s the same problem we have now with calling MAGA “Conservatives”. They aren’t, they are right-wing reactionaries, but the usage of the label is being changed over time. Same with “Communist”: many conflate it with Stalinism, which is very different.
mcdltlover on
the rowers are paddling in opposite directions, this ship is going in circles
SamuelHuzzahAdams on
“They both are on a boat” -stupid m’fer somewhere in the comments who definitely believed the separate but equal part of Jim Crow
12D_D21 on
This is neither capitalism nor socialism, this is a figure representing exploitation. It can happen in both systems and both systems can exist without having it. Stop saying it is “literally X” and creating an artificial division, economic systems go alongside political systems and neither is a black and white issue.
tayt087x on
The real issue is that they’re rowing a sailboat
_Tar_Ar_Ais_ on
If you’re in the west, you are the upper class relying on a permanent underclass to keep things going. Count yourself lucky!
24 Comments
I refuse to believe the people around me arw actually this far gone man…
“Socialism is when capitalists…”
https://preview.redd.it/jtxea7f2cc0h1.jpeg?width=998&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ee79a9c1e54f6459cafc023eeab945815b5b0e97
It’s absolutely amazing that people who actively comment on economic models don’t actually understand them. Why don’t they use google if their education failed them? Mind boggling.
Education is so important to a functioning society.
We are a nation of marks
One of the best tricks performed against the working class was convincing them all the bad stuff in the world wasn’t in part caused by capitalism, so the more bad stuff means we aren’t capitalisming hard enough. Gotta throw more money at top percenters and corpos so they can “make jobs” and “reinvest in the region”.
All of the rowers should be seated facing the same way with their backs to the prow
Management: “We’re all on the same boat together.”
The boat:
The real problem this image demonstrates is that this is what communism looks like when it goes wrong, but what capitalism looks like when it’s working exactly as designed.
Homo sapiens you mean
Where the fuck is that boat going with that rower bank config?
Both are wrong, that’s oligarchy period.
Are we sure it’s not aristocracy?
Is that a picture of Bezos yacht?
This image could apply to both equally. In both societies you have rich and poor. Communism doesn’t magically erase societal classes at least it hasn’t in any society it’s been implemented in.
The problem is there has never been a genuinely Communist state, in which the workers actually owned and controlled the means of production. There were a series of dictators from Stalin on in Russia and Mao on in China. In Russia or China, the apparatchik leaders would be the ones on the top deck and the ordinary workers are the galley slaves.
It’s the same problem we have now with calling MAGA “Conservatives”. They aren’t, they are right-wing reactionaries, but the usage of the label is being changed over time. Same with “Communist”: many conflate it with Stalinism, which is very different.
the rowers are paddling in opposite directions, this ship is going in circles
“They both are on a boat” -stupid m’fer somewhere in the comments who definitely believed the separate but equal part of Jim Crow
This is neither capitalism nor socialism, this is a figure representing exploitation. It can happen in both systems and both systems can exist without having it. Stop saying it is “literally X” and creating an artificial division, economic systems go alongside political systems and neither is a black and white issue.
The real issue is that they’re rowing a sailboat
If you’re in the west, you are the upper class relying on a permanent underclass to keep things going. Count yourself lucky!
Communism sucks!
Why isn’t it both?